Contact Us Today!



May 3, 2018

Are auto body repair shops being forced by insurers to use inferior or broken replacement parts to do repairs on cars involved in accidents?

Wattel & York, one of Arizona’s leading personal injury law firms, reports on recent allegations that some of the nation’s top insurers are cutting corners on car repair authorizations, which in turn, enable them to save costs and increase their profits. As a result, insured drivers who have had repairs are unknowingly risking their lives by driving unsafe vehicles with substandard parts.

Although it is the car owners that are the ultimate victims of such auto repair fraud,it is the honest auto body repair shops themselves that are now speaking out against the insurers for steering owners toward shops that are authorized by the insurers to do repairs. These shops may be more than willing to take advantage of consumers by not questioning the steady flow of business that comes from insurance companies.

According to Edmunds.com, the consumer can’t rely completely on body shops or insurance companies to watch out for their interests. You have to act as your own advocate, choose the best shop and remain alert to overcharging and misrepresentation.


A Missouri repair shop owner, John Mosley, clarified how the insurance companies are using steering to game the system by pushing car owners to shops that, in his estimation, have been coerced to do the repairs or lose the business. “The insurance companies have set up networks of shops (called) direct repair programs. And the way these shops’ performance is measured is by the amount that it costs to repair cars at this particular shop…Just get the car in, make it look like it’s fixed, and get it out the door.”

Matt Parker, owner of Parker Auto Body in Monroe, LA, was more outspoken. He showed reporters a broken replacement headlight with a cracked lens for a Toyota that had been glued back together, wrapped up, and put in a new box for delivery to his shop to use on a customer’s car. “The insurance company wants us to put this stuff on their cars. If we refuse to use the part, then they label us as a shop not willing to go along with their program, and then they try to steer our business away from us.” He concluded, “This is refurbished junk is what it is. This is junk.”


US Senator Richard Blumenthal is urging the Department of Justice to step in and investigate the insidious practice of insurance companies enriching themselves by steering car owners to shops that are either unscrupulous or not being given the resources needed to do proper repairs.

Wattel & York has been going toe to toe with major insurance companies for fifteen years in personal injury and car accident cases. Allstate, State Farm, Farmers, Progressive, and others all know the experience of doing battle with Wattel & York and coming up on the losing end when a client’s rights have been challenged. If you are in need of a Phoenix personal injury lawyer as a result of a faulty repair, contact us now so we can start to fight for you. We serve all of Arizona, including Tucson, Chandler, Glendale and Yuma. Call 1-877-225-5562 to schedule a free case review to discuss your options. 


  1. Edmunds.com, Confessions from an Auto Body Shop http://www.edmunds.com/car-care/confessions-from-the-auto-body-shop.html
  2. Body Shop Business, Anderson Cooper Show Uncovers Insurance Fraud http://www.bodyshopbusiness.com/anderson-cooper-show-uncover-insurance-fraud/
  3. CNN.com, Auto Insurers Accused of Pushing Cheap and Dangerous Repairs http://www.cnn.com/2015/02/11/us/auto-repair-investigation/

Find more like this: Personal Injury , Arizona accident lawyers, Phoenix car accident lawsuit

Online Reviews

“Amazing people, they had my claim for about a week before they were able to get my truck totaled out. Otherwise I would have been stuck with a truck that had heavy front end damage if they hadn’t stepped in to help me. I tried to deal with my insurance company myself for over a month and that got me nowhere, all I got was a massive headache and a messed up truck. They are very professional and act quickly on your claim. I highly recommend them to anyone who is looking for help.”

Candy J.


“I was in an accident and decided to call Wattel and York. After months of going to a Chiropractor, I finally felt better. When it came time for settlement, the insurance company was making an offer I wanted to accept, Mr. Wattel advised against it and felt the insurance company was shortchanging me. He recommended I file a lawsuit and that will get them to cave. Well, Dave filed suit, and sure enough, the insurance company increased their offer by $4,000! I am very satisfied with how my case was handled.”

Nardeasha S.


“Wattel & York were flat out outstanding with my personal injury case. They made the process painless and kept in constant communication throughout the entire time. Any questions I might’ve had were promptly answered and detail oriented. They gave me crucial advice that I would’ve otherwise not been aware of. I couldn’t have asked for more from them. Put your trust in these guys, you won’t be disappointed. Thanks Wattel & York.”

Mattew P.


“Thank you so much for all your hard work on our behalf! Thinking I could handle it on my own, I was originally reluctant to take my accident claim to an attorney. But I am SO glad I called you instead. Your people were always helpful, pleasant and responsive at every step along the way. You represented us with honesty and integrity and made a traumatic experience as painless as it could be. And best of all, you helped us get a settlement that was fair and far more than I could ever have negotiated on my own! I highly recommend Wattel &York to anyone who has suffered a personal injury.”

Cathy M.

“I was the passenger in a vehicle that was 'T- Boned' at an intersection in 2014. The issues of responsibility and recovery became a difficult and convoluted confusion. I really needed help. This Team at Wattel and York walked me patiently and encouragingly through difficult months, sorting through issues and finally arriving at a satisfactory conclusion. I especially want to name two great and encouraging "warriors" of Wattel and York who directed me along the way..Brian Torba and Melissa Patterson..to them and the whole team I say "Thank You" with heart felt gratitude. Sincerely, God Bless You.”

Robert G.

“Honesty. Integrity. Transparency. Partnership. Wattel & York brought all of these qualities and more to my accident case. I'd love to thank all of the team members who helped me with the process: David Guzman, who conducted the initial interview in my home, Aly Shomar-Esparza, who seamlessly guided me through paperwork and filings, Debbie Harrach, who conducted final review, paperwork revisions and scheduling, and Thomas Grisoni, who counseled me before and attended my deposition. I never felt alone during the arduous process and always knew there was a professional team looking out for my best interest. I highly recommend Wattel & York if you are unfortunately involved in an accident that was not your fault.”

Russ W.

“I was a passenger in a car that got t-boned a few years ago and got a huge gash. I didn't know a lot about lawyers, so I basically just picked one on the flip of a coin. I called Wattel and York and they explained everything, I went into the office and filled out paperwork. Got treatment on my gash over the time I worked with them, glad I did as it opened back up a couple times and bled. They did really good, got me the maximum amount of money, and made sure I was well taken care of. I was updated from time to time so that was good. The only thing I might change is I never got to thank or talk to my lawyer. I think it was because I was already used to dealing with the lady at their Glendale office so they just kept her as my point of contact. So it's okay, I'll thank them with a good review. The last thing I could say about them is months after I thought my case was over they called me and said they had another check for me for a few hundred dollars. Apparently, they negotiated with the hospital I went to after the accident. It was a nice surprise and shows they really had my interests in mind.”

Trent B.

“Wattel & York has been great for me in the past few years. I was involved in a really bad accident while I was on Active Duty in Yuma, Arizona and they have been patient with me every step of the way through a very long process. I would recommend them to anyone thank you for all your help.”

Levy G.

“Appreciate David taking the time to speak with me. He was most kind. From the front line with the receptionist, to him, the firm was a class act all the way around.”

Claire B.

“Dave Wattel represented me and my son on a Personal Injury case from a motor vehicle accident back in 2009. Jake P. handled my deposition and Dave did the Quarterbacking. The insurance company hired NFL referee Ed Hochuli's firm to try and deny our claim. But Wattel & York made it look as easy as Tom Brady on the football field. The result was more than acceptable and my son and I were compensated for our injuries and rehabilitation. Dave Wattel cares about his clients. If I ever find myself in a situation like this again, Wattel & York will be on speed dial!!”

Vince C.

Our Office Locations


2175 N. Alma School Rd #B-107 Chandler, AZ 85224

Map & Directions [+]


4901 W. Glendale Avenue Glendale, AZ 85301

Map & Directions [+]


2942 N. 24th Street, Suite 105 Phoenix, AZ 85016

Map & Directions [+]


2933 N. Campbell Ave. Tucson, AZ 85719

Map & Directions [+]


1102 S. 4th Avenue Yuma AZ, 85364

Map & Directions [+]

Newport Beach

260 Newport Center Drive, Suite 100 Newport Beach, CA 92660

Map & Directions [+]


6314 19th Street West, Suite 15 Fircrest, WA 98466

Map & Directions [+]

Phone Number


Follow Our Firm


Contact Us Today For
Your Free Consultation

We are available to assist you 24 hours a day!